NCLAT: Can’t Dismiss Restoration App. if Filed in 30 Days from Date of Dismissal of Original App.  ||  Delhi HC: Communication between Parties through Whatsapp Constitute Valid Agreement  ||  Delhi HC Seeks Response from Govt. Over Penalties on Petrol Pumps Supplying Fuel to Old Vehicles  ||  Centre Notifies "Unified Waqf Management, Empowerment, Efficiency and Development Rules, 2025"  ||  Del. HC: Can’t Reject TM Owner’s Claim Merely because Defendant Could have Sought Removal of Mark  ||  Bombay HC: Cannot Treat Sole Director of OPC, Parallelly with Separate Legal Entity  ||  Delhi HC: Can Apply 'Family of Marks' Concept to Injunct Specific Marks  ||  HP HC: Can’t Set Aside Ex-Parte Decree for Mere Irregularity  ||  Cal. HC: Order by HC Bench Not Conferred With Determination by Roster is Void  ||  Calcutta HC: Purchase Order Including Arbitration Agreement to Prevail Over Tax Invoice Lacking it    

Standard Chartered Bank v. Andhra Bank Financial Services Ltd. and Ors. - (Supreme Court) (28 Aug 2015)

Knowledge of a specific person against whom a suit can be instituted is required under “first learns”

MANU/SC/0935/2015

Civil

The Supreme Court held that Standard Chartered Bank's claim borne from a purchase of bonds worth nearly Rs. 50 crores for which it only received a photocopy of the letter for allotment was not time barred. Noting that under Article 91(a) of the Schedule in Limitation Act, 1963, the period of limitation started running from the date when the person 'first learns' about the conversion of moveable property, a certain degree of knowledge had to be attributed to meet the requirement. A mere suspicion or a whisper of knowledge was not enough for the period of limitation to start running. Given the facts of the case, the Court determined 'first learns' required knowing the identity of a specific person in whose possession the bonds were and that he acquired the possession of the said bonds under an arrangement, which in law would constitute wrongful conversion.

Relevant : K.S. Nanji and Co. v. Jatashankar Dossa and Ors. MANU/SC/0252/1961 Sarat Kamini Das v. Nagendra Nath Pal MANU/WB/0459/1925 Standard Chartered Bank v. Andhra Bank Financial Services Ltd. and Ors. MANU/SC/2534/2006

Tags : BOND   LIMITATION   FIRST LEARNS   KNOWLEDGE  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2025 - All Rights Reserved