SC: Recoveries U/S 27 of Evidence Act Alone Cannot Sustain Conviction; 1988 Murder Acquittal Restored  ||  SC: Successive Impleadment Applications are Barred by Res Judicata under Different CPC Provisions  ||  Supreme Court Halts Coercive Measures in CJP Protest Cases, Directs Release of Minors  ||  Supreme Court: National Commission for Scheduled Castes Lacks Power to Pass Binding Orders  ||  Bombay HC: Alleged Illegal Arrest Alone Cannot Trigger Contempt Action Against Police  ||  Bombay HC Quashes Order against Taiwan National, Says Online Study Didn't Breach Visa Rules  ||  P&H High Court Issues Directions on LADC Scheme After Reviewing Lawyers' Objections  ||  Allahabad HC: Suspension of Sentence Plea Need Not Take Priority if Appeal is Ready  ||  Allahabad High Court: Surcharge Recovery From Pradhan Must Follow Panchayat Raj Act Procedure  ||  Allahabad HC Directs IB Probe into 4 Lucknow Lawyers, Raises Concern over Lawyer-Police Nexus    

State of West Bengal and ors. v. Calcutta Club Limited - (Supreme Court) (04 Jun 2016)

Larger bench to resolve dilemma over sales tax on club F&B

Sales Tax/VAT

A Division Bench of Justices Dipak Misra and Shiva Kirti Singh referred to a larger Bench of the Supreme Court to decide if food and beverage sold by incorporated clubs to permanent members is liable to sales tax. Two earlier decisions of the court were deemed inadequate precedent on the issue, for not clarifying the applicability of the doctrine of mutuality. The Respondent-Club had contended that rather than sell food and beverage items to its members, it was merely an agent for the members and no consideration passed for the supply of such items.

Relevant : Section 2 Companies Act, 1956

Clause 29A Article 366 Constitution Act

Tags : SALES TAX   CLUB   PERMANENT MEMBERS   F&B  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved