Madras HC: Freedom of Religion Cannot Extend to Disturbing Peace Within Temple Premises  ||  Delhi HC: Lokpal Cannot Form a Prima Facie View on Corruption Without Hearing The Official  ||  MP High Court: DRT Cannot Restrict or Impose Conditions on a Person's Foreign Travel  ||  Bombay HC: Results of Dec 2 And 20 Local Body Election Must be Declared Together  ||  Delhi HC: Employment Disputes Cannot be Treated as Commercial Cases under the Act  ||  Supreme Court: Divorced Muslim Woman Can Reclaim Gifts Given to Husband at Marriage  ||  Supreme Court: Police and Courts Should Act as Initial Filters to Prevent Baseless Prosecutions  ||  SC: Maharashtra Can Acquire Land under Slum Areas Act, Respecting Owner's Preferential Rights  ||  Supreme Court: Excise Exemption on Cotton Fabrics is Denied if Any Related Process Uses Power  ||  NCLAT: IBC Auctions are Not Ordinary Contracts, and Market Volatility Does not Excuse Bid Defaults    

The State of Western Australia vs. Latimer - (28 Aug 2023)

Court cannot release an offender on a supervision order unless satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the offender will substantially comply with the standard conditions of the order

Criminal

Present is a contravention hearing under the High Risk Serious Offenders Act, 2020 (HRSO Act) in respect of the Respondent, Edward Latimer. As at the date of the application, the Respondent was subject to a 10 year supervision order, which commenced on 31 July 2019. The State alleges the respondent has contravened the supervision order on four occasions, and has applied for an order rescinding the supervision order and making a continuing detention order.

The powers conferred by the HRSO Act are not to be exercised for the purpose of imposing additional punishment on the offender, but rather for the ultimate purpose of protecting the community.

In deciding which order to make, the paramount consideration is to be the need to ensure adequate protection of the community.A continuing detention order is an order that the offender be detained in custody for an indefinite term for control, care or treatment.A supervision order is an order that the offender, when not in custody, is to be subject to stated conditions that the court considers to be appropriate in accordance with Section 30 of the HRSO Act. The court cannot release an offender on a supervision order unless satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the offender will substantially comply with the standard conditions of the order, the onus of establishing which is on the offender.

Condition, in combination with the other conditions of the Supervision Order, will ensure adequate protection of the community against the unacceptable risk that the respondent would, if not subject to restriction, commit a serious offence. Present Court is satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the Respondent will substantially comply with the standard conditions of the Supervision Order. The outstanding term of the Supervision Order is presently sufficient and that it is not necessary to extend the term.

Tags : SUPERVISION ORDER   RELEASE   CONDITIONS  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2025 - All Rights Reserved