SC: No Remand if the Appellate Court Can Decide the Issue on Existing Evidence  ||  SC: S.69 Evidence Act Applies to Will Only if S.68 Attestation Proof is Impossible  ||  SC: Superior’s Mere Reprimand Not Abetment of Suicide without Intent to Provoke Death  ||  SC: Speedy Trial is Victim’s Right; Gangsters Act Case Cannot Stall Other Trials  ||  Supreme Court Issues Directions to Curb Unaccounted Cash in Elections to Protect Democracy  ||  Supreme Court Issues Directions to Prevent Fake Sureties in Bail Cases Involving Foreigners  ||  Madras HC: Police Cannot Arbitrarily Bar Carrying Indian Flag at Peaceful Rallies  ||  Delhi HC Bars JNU from Granting Student Admissions Using Deprivation Points  ||  Kerala High Court Flags Misuse of POCSO in Marital Disputes and Acquits Man Accused of Rape  ||  Calcutta HC orders Urgent EWS Certificate Decision, Says Mother's Voter Deletion Irrelevant    

Mamta Khadotiya vs. Union Of India - (High Court of Bombay) (18 Aug 2023)

Prior show cause notice granting reasonable opportunity of being heard is essential element of all administrative decision-making

MANU/MH/3239/2023

Commercial

Instituting present proceeding under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, 1950, a challenge has been laid by the petitioner to an order to the extent the said order debars/blacklists the petitioner from participating in the bid process of catering licence of a contract for any Zonal Railways-IRCTC for a period of 5 (five) years. Under challenge is another order whereby the debarment order has been reiterated by the Divisional Commercial Manager.

As a matter of fact, the notices, did not call upon the Petitioner to show cause why debarment order may not be passed. Any notice issued requiring the petitioner to make deposit of the licence fees does not fulfill the requirement of show cause notice which is necessarily to be issued before passing of an order of debarment/blacklisting. In absence of such notice, the impugned order is in clear violation of the principles of natural justice and hence, the same cannot be sustained.

The law in regard to debarment/blacklisting is very clear. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of UMC Technologies Private Limited vs. Food Corporation of India and Anr. has clearly observed that a prior show cause notice granting reasonable opportunity of being heard is an essential element of all administrative decision-making and particularly so in decisions pertaining to blacklisting which entail grave consequences. The orders are set aside. It will, however, be open to the Respondents to take decision afresh after issuing proper show cause notice. Petition disposed off.

Tags : DEBARMENT ORDER   SCN   ISSUANCE  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved