Delhi HC: Property Disputes Between In-Laws and Daughter-In-Law are Not Exclusively For Family Court  ||  Delhi High Court: After Probate is Granted, A Will Does Not Require Fresh Proof under Section 68  ||  Ker HC: Periodic Replacement and Maintenance of Prosthetic Limb Must Be Included in Compensation  ||  Madras High Court: DNA Test Not Required For Mother to Donate Kidney to Her Son  ||  Delhi HC: Pre-Summoning Evidence Opportunity Must be Granted Even in Civil-Natured Criminal Cases  ||  J&K&L HC: UAPA Trials Cannot Linger and Must Proceed With Day-To-Day Hearing under NIA Act  ||  Allahabad HC: FIR in Disproportionate Assets Case Not Vitiated For Lack of Pre-Registration Hearing  ||  Allahabad HC: FIR in Disproportionate Assets Case Not Vitiated For Lack of Pre-Registration Hearing  ||  Delhi HC: Private Schools May Increase Fees Without Prior Approval if Declared Before Session Begins  ||  Supreme Court: Omission of Accused in Inquest Report Alone Does Not Indicate Innocence    

Manisha Rajendra Kamble Vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors. - (High Court of Bombay) (25 Jul 2023)

Any relief based on a contract of personal service cannot be enforced in exercise of writ jurisdiction

MANU/MH/2840/2023

Service

In facts of present case, the Petitioner came to be appointed as an Assistant Teacher at Respondent no.6-Junior College that is being run by Respondent no.5-Management. The services of the Petitioner came to be approved on 18th October, 2013 for a period of two years. By Government Resolution dated 30th June, 2014, the School was held entitled to partial grant-in-aid. The benefit in that regard came to be enhanced as per the policy of the State Government. The services of the Petitioner came to be dispensed with on 27th June, 2017.

The Petitioner made a representation seeking salary for the period from 1st November, 2011 to 28th June, 2017. The representation made by the Petitioner was replied by the Management on 8th July, 2017 stating therein that since the services of the Petitioner were approved on no grant basis, it was the responsibility of the Education Officer (Secondary) to release her salary. On that count, the Management refused to make any payment to her. In this backdrop, the present Writ Petition has been filed praying that the Management and the School be directed to pay the petitioner her salary.

The Petitioner is claiming monetary relief in the form of arrears of salary for the period from 1st November, 2011 to 28th June, 2017. Ordinarily, a monetary claim prior to three years of filing of Writ Petition would not be entertained in view of the general principles of limitation by applying a period of three years as the limit within which any monetary relief as due could be claimed. For this reason, the claim from 1st November, 2011 to 31st July, 2014 would relate to the period beyond three years of filing of the Writ Petition. Since the relief of grant of arrears of salary for this period could not have been obtained by approaching the Civil Court, that relief will have to be held to be not entertainable on account of unexplained delay and latches.

Further, any relief based on a contract of personal service which includes the relief with regard to a claim for arrears of salary amongst other reliefs cannot be enforced in exercise of writ jurisdiction. It is only if there is a public law element involved that such relief can be sought in exercise of writ jurisdiction. The relief with regard to enforcing a contract of personal service cannot be so sought. Individual wrongs or breach of mutual contracts without having any public element as its integral part cannot be rectified through a Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

The only relief sought by the Petitioner is for grant of arrears of salary. The said relief is in the nature of seeking enforcement of terms of contract of personal service. The Writ Petition would not be tenable.The Petitioner is at liberty to seek such relief as is permissible in law by taking recourse to appropriate proceedings. Petition dismissed.

Tags : ARREARS   SALARY   ENTITLEMENT  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved