Supreme Court Awards Rs. 6 Lakh to Man Acquitted After 6 Years, Faults UP Police Probe  ||  Supreme Court: High Courts Can Restore Power on 50% Deposit in Arbitrary Theft Assessments  ||  Supreme Court: Cooperative Society Cannot Deny RTI Records as Personal if Registrar Can Access Them  ||  SC: CoC Cannot Withdraw Approved Resolution Plan Over Improved Corporate Debtor Finances  ||  Delhi High Court: 24-Week Limit Alone Cannot Restrict Medical Termination of Pregnancy  ||  Allahabad High Court Rejects Challenge to 18% GST on Online Legal Database Services  ||  Madras High Court: FIR Registration Does Not Decide Guilt; Prior Hearing of Accused Not Required  ||  Kerala High Court Orders Speedy Prosecution Sanction Process in Sabarimala Gold Theft Case  ||  Allahabad HC: Missing RT-PCR Report Cannot Bar COVID-19 Compensation if Records Confirm Infection  ||  MP High Court Directs Indore Police to Deploy Volunteers for Reporting Noise Pollution Violations    

Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. N.S. Software - (High Court of Delhi) (10 Jul 2023)

Assessee need not to demonstrate commercial expediency in each year concerning a loan transaction

MANU/DE/4379/2023

Direct Taxation

In facts of present case, the Assessing Officer (AO) concluded that, the disallowance was mandated in view of the fact that the Respondent/Assessee had not been able to demonstrate "commercial expediency". Accordingly, the AO disallowed interest expenses amounting to Rs. 5,16,16,215in proportion to the non-interest bearing advances extended to each of the partners.

The Respondent/Assessee, being aggrieved by the order, preferred an appeal with the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). CIT(A), via order, reversed the view taken by the AO. The Appellant/revenue carried the matter in appeal to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ["Tribunal"]. The Tribunal concurred with the CIT(A) and dismissed the appeal of the Appellant/revenue.

The moot point which arises for consideration is, does the Respondent/Assessee need to demonstrate commercial expediency in each year concerning a loan transaction which took place in and about AY 2005-06?

If the loan availed on account of stated commercial expediency, which has, in a sense, received the imprimatur of the Appellant/revenue, when the loan was first taken and several years thereafter, surely, the Respondent/Assessee is not required, once again, to demonstrate commercial expediency in each year. The AO seems to have disregarded this aspect in the AY in issue.

Second, the interest expenditure is revenue neutral. In case this was to be disallowed in the hands of respondent/assessee i.e., the partnership firm, it would have to be allowed in the hands of the partners. Present Court is not inclined to interfere with the decision of the Tribunal.

Tags : ASSESSMENT   INTEREST EXPENSES   DISALLOWANCE  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved