NCLT: Suspended Directors Who are Prospective Resolution Applicants Cann’t Access Valuation Reports  ||  Supreme Court Clarifies Test For Granting Bail to Accused Added at Trial under Section 319 CrPC  ||  SC: Fresh Notification For Vijayawada ACB Police Station not Required After AP Bifurcation  ||  SC: Studying in a Government Institute Does Not Create an Automatic Right to a Government Job  ||  NCLT Mumbai: CIRP Claims Cannot Invoke the 12-Year Limitation Period For Enforcing Mortgage Rights  ||  NCLAT: Misnaming Guarantor as 'Director' in SARFAESI Notice Doesn't Void Guarantee Invocation  ||  Jharkhand HC: Mere Breach of Compromise Terms by an Accused Does Not Justify Bail Cancellation  ||  Cal HC: Banks Cannot Freeze a Company's Accounts Solely Due To ROC Labeling a 'Management Dispute'  ||  Rajasthan HC: Father’s Rape of His Daughter Transcends Ordinary Crime; Victim’s Testimony Suffices  ||  Delhi HC: Judge Who Reserved Judgment Must Deliver Verdict Despite Transfer; Successor Can't Rehear    

BLS Infrastructure Limited Vs. Rajwant Singh and Ors. - (Supreme Court) (01 Mar 2023)

Where the complainant had already been examined as a witness in the case, Court cannot acquit accused merely on non-appearance of the complainant

MANU/SC/0185/2023

Criminal

Present appeals are directed against the judgment and order passed by Delhi High Court dismissing petition filed by the Appellant against the order learned Magistrate dismissing Criminal Complaints for non-appearance of the complainant (the Appellant).

The short question that arises for consideration in present appeals is whether in the facts of the case, the learned Magistrate was justified in dismissing the criminal complaints for non-appearance of the complainant even though the statement of the complainant had been recorded and, vide order of the learned Magistrate, the complainant's evidence was closed with a direction to list the matter for recording of defence evidence as also for consideration of application under Section 311 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) filed by the complainant.

Where the complainant had already been examined as a witness in the case, it would not be appropriate for the Court to pass an order of acquittal merely on non-appearance of the complainant. Thus, the order of acquittal was set-aside and it was directed that the prosecution would proceed from the stage where it reached before the order of acquittal was passed.

There is a specific averment in the Petition that the Appellant had led its evidence in the case and thereafter had moved an application Under Section 311 of the CrPC to summon and examine further witnesses. The trial court as well as the High Court did not take into consideration that the complainant's cross-examination had been over in Complaint Cases, and no cross-examination was sought in other cases. There appears no specific denial of the aforesaid factual position. However, neither the High Court nor the learned Magistrate has taken notice of the aforesaid position. Both the courts below thus failed to consider whether in the facts of the case under the proviso to Sub-section (1) of Section 256, the court could proceed with the matter after dispensing with the attendance of the complainant.

Further, if the complainant had not appeared to press the application under Section 311 of the CrPC, the learned Magistrate could have rejected the application under Section 311 of the CrPC and proceeded with the case on basis of the available evidence. The learned Magistrate was not justified in straight away dismissing the complaint and ordering acquittal of the Accused on mere non-appearance of the complainant.

The orders of the High Court as well as of the learned Magistrate are set-aside. The proceedings shall stand restored to their original number on the file of the learned Magistrate and the prosecution shall now proceed from the stage where it was when the order of acquittal/dismissal of the complaint was passed. Appeals allowed.

Tags : NON-APPEARANCE   ACQUITTAL   LEGALITY  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved