SC: Menstrual Health is a Fundamental Right under Article 21; Orders Free Sanitary Pads in Schools  ||  Supreme Court: Industrial Court is the Proper Forum to Decide Issues Relating to Contract Labour  ||  Supreme Court: Only Civil Court of Original Jurisdiction Can Extend Arbitral Tribunal’s Mandate  ||  SC: Demolition of Private Property Must Rest on Clear Statutory Grounds and Due Consideration  ||  SC: After Complaint Was Withdrawn, BCI Disciplinary Committee Could Not Penalise Advocate  ||  MP HC: Decree Holder Cannot Defeat Compromise or Initiate Execution by Refusing Debtor’s Cheque  ||  MP HC: Spouse’s Income Cannot Be Clubbed With Public Servant’s for Disproportionate Assets Case  ||  Ker HC: Bar Association is Not Employer & Cannot Form Internal Complaints Committee under POSH Act  ||  SC: Ex-Contract Workers Must Be Preferred When Employers Replace Contract Labour With Regular Staff  ||  SC: Waqf Tribunals Cannot Hear Claims over Properties Not Listed or Registered under Waqf Act    

The State of Bombay v. Narasu Appa Mali - (High Court of Bombay) (24 Jul 1951)

Personal laws not disturbed by fundamental rights

MANU/MH/0040/1952

Constitution

What could the Bombay High Court have said that stung Finance Minister Arun Jaitley so, leading him to call it “one of the most adverse judgments”. After all in 1951 the Bombay High Court, dissecting the Bombay Prevention of Hindu Bigamous Marriages Act, 1946, held that “even if the State Legislature has infringed upon Hindu religion or its practice as alleged, it would be perfectly competent for the State Legislature to do so, if it is legislating for social welfare and reform”. Subsequently upholding the aforementioned Act, it appears to have concreted positive social change in the shift away from bigamy to monogamous marriages in Hindus. Perhaps Mr Jaitley’s angst lies in personal laws being escaped from the ambit of Article 13 of the Constitution. Held to not form part of the “laws in force”, the decision allowed polygamy to subsist in other religions, possibly in contravention of Article 15.

Relevant : Article 13 of the Constitution of India Act Article 15 of the Constitution of India Act Article 25 of the Constitution of India Act

Tags : PERSONAL LAWS   BIGAMY   FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS   SOCIAL CUSTOM  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved