Karnataka HC Directs Authorities to Not Grant Permission for Construction Near Protected Monuments  ||  Delhi HC Sets Aside Ruling to the Extent of Restraining Indiamart to Provide ‘PUMA’ Search Option  ||  HP HC Grants Bail to NDPS Accused Citing Delay in Initiating Trial Proceedings  ||  Madras HC: Certification of an Entire Film Cannot be Denied Without Specifying the Objections  ||  J&K HC: Mere Registration of Criminal Case Doesn’t Constitute ‘Criminal Proc.’ for Impounding Passpor  ||  SC Refuses to Entertain Urgent Hearing of Plea Against Felling 875 Trees in HP  ||  SC Refuses to Stop Incineration of Toxic Chemical Waste from Bhopal Gas Tragedy  ||  SC Declines to Interfere with HC’s Order to Decide Schedule for Tiruchendur Temple Consecration  ||  Delhi High Court Grants Interim Relief to Mokobara in Trademark Case  ||  Delhi HC: Students Shouldn’t be Excluded from Admission because of Untimely Declaration of Results    

Navinchandra Mafatlal v. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay City - (Supreme Court) (01 Nov 1954)

Giving a constitutional enactment the widest possible meaning

MANU/SC/0070/1954

Direct Taxation

It seems prerequisite that any case seeking to send aftershocks into the legal system should have the word Mafatlal in it. Certainly, Mr. Mafatlal here may not quite comprise the elite constitutional club of his eponymous brethren, but its amplitude is no less wide. Considering if capital gain could be construed as income, the Court concluded that income in “its natural meaning embraces any profit or gain which is actually received”. In its obiter the Court provided much interpretational fodder and freedom to courts in the future; it noted, “words [in a constitutional enactment] should be read in their ordinary, natural and grammatical meaning… the most liberal construction should be upon the words”.

Relevant : Wallace Brothers and Co. Ltd. vs. The Commissioner of Income Tax MANU/PR/0011/1948 United Provinces vs. Mt. Atiqa Begum and Ors. MANU/FE/0003/1940 The State of Bombay and Anr. vs. F.N. Balsara MANU/SC/0009/1951

Tags : INCOME   CONSTITUTION   INTERPRETATION   WIDEST   NATURAL MEANING  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2025 - All Rights Reserved