SC: POCSO Guilt Presumption Not Absolute, Acquits Accused  ||  Supreme Court: Promotion Cannot Be Claimed as a Vested Right under Repealed Rules  ||  Supreme Court: Promotion Cannot Be Claimed as a Vested Right under Repealed Rules  ||  SC: Unexplained 5-Day Sample Custody Gap Breached S.52A, Acquits 2 after 20 Years  ||  P&H High Court: Illegal Search Alone Does Not Justify Quashing of Complaint under PNDT Act  ||  Bom HC: Creating WhatsApp Group Without Employer's Permission Not Ground for Compulsory Retirement  ||  Madras HC: Lack of Son’s Moral Support Alone Cannot Sustain Father’s Maintenance Claim under CrPC  ||  Kerala HC: University Professor doesn't Occupy 'Public Office', Quo Warranto Not Maintainable  ||  Bombay HC Allows Cutting of 1,237 Mangroves for Connector Bridge in Mumbai’s Western Suburbs  ||  Calcutta HC Orders Return of 3-Year-Old to Adoptive Couple, he wasn't Abandoned    

Ashok Kumar and Ors v. State of J&K and Ors - (High Court of Jammu and Kashmir) (09 Oct 2015)

“Article 370 only provision of Constitution that applies to [J&K] on its own”

Constitution

In a petition against the accelerated promotion of government servants in Jammu and Kashmir, under the auspices of reservation, the Jammu and Kashmir High Court narrated the birth of the State’s unique legal status, as compared to the rest of the country. Reiterating that “Article 370 of the Constitution embodies conceptual framework of relationship between Union of India and State”, it pointed out that Article 370 was the only provision in the Constitution that applied to the State itself, with even Article 1 made applicable by it. Terming it a permanent provision, notwithstanding its actual title, the Court added “[Article 370] cannot be abrogated, repealed or even amended”. In its obiter, the Court also allowed petitions against promotion of junior government servants over their more senior colleagues on the basis of reservation as the provisions relating to such appointments had not been extended to the State of Jammu and Kashmir by the President.

Tags : ARTICLE 370   CONSTITUTION   JAMMU AND KASHMIR   STATUS  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved