Calcutta HC: Demolition Orders Cannot be Challenged under Article 226 if a Statutory Appeal Exists  ||  Kerala High Court: Disability Pension is Payable to Voluntary Dischargee For Service-Related Illness  ||  Calcutta High Court: Partition Decree is Executable Only After Stamp Duty Payment  ||  Calcutta HC: Contempt Court Cannot Grant New Relief Beyond Original Order Once Compliance is Met  ||  Kerala High Court: Intentional Judicial Decisions Cannot be Altered as Clerical Errors under CPC  ||  Supreme Court: Delay In Filing Appeals under Section 74 of 2013 Land Acquisition Act is Condonable  ||  SC: Statutory Authorities may Intervene When Housing Societies Delay Membership Decisions  ||  SC: Quasi-Judicial Authorities Cannot Exercise Review Powers Unless Expressly Granted By Statute  ||  SC: Special Court Cannot Order Confiscation While Appeal Against Attachment Confirmation is Pending  ||  SC: Photocopies are Not Evidence Unless Conditions for Leading Secondary Evidence are Proved    

Subaya Constructions Co. Ltd. Vs. The Commissioner, Vellore City Municipal Corporation and Ors. - (High Court of Madras) (05 Apr 2018)

If decision relating to award of contract is bona fide and in public interest, Courts will not interfere, even if, a procedural error in assessment or prejudice to a tenderer, is made out

MANU/TN/1696/2018

Commercial

The Petitioner has come forward with instant Writ Petitions for issuance of Writ of Mandamus directing the first Respondent to accept the Work Completion Certificate dated 17th September, 2016 submitted by the Petitioner for processing the tender proceeding in NCB No. 81/2017-18, for providing Sewerage Collection System for UGSS in Vellore Corporation under Packages I and II, tender proceeding No. CNT/SEW/NCB/AMRUT-ADB/001/2017-2018 for providing Comprehensive Sewerage Scheme to Manali, Chinnasekkadu, Karambakkam and Manapakkam in Chennai City; tender proceeding in No. NCB No. 223/2017-18 for providing Sewerage Collection System in the extended areas of Corporation for UGSS in Trichy Corporation under Package I, respectively.

In the instant case, the Petitioner is one of the participants in the tender floated by the first Respondent and as per the tender conditions, a work completion certificate has been produced along with the tender documents. According to the First Respondent, the execution of the work is complex in nature and also involves huge financial implications, so to ensure proper execution of the work and in the public interest, the decision was taken to get opinion of the genuineness of the completion certificate of all the tenderers. The Apex Court in Jagdish Mandal vs. State of Orissa and Ors., if the decision relating to award of contract is bona fide and is in public interest, the Courts will not, in exercise of power of judicial review, interfere even if a procedural aberration or error in assessment or prejudice to a tenderer, is made out. The petitioner except making vague allegations, has not produced any materials to show that the action of the first respondent is arbitrary and it has been adopted to eliminate the petitioner from the tender process. Therefore, there is no force in the contention of the learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner.

It is also relevant to note that, in response to the letter of the First Respondent, an opinion about the performance of the Petitioner has been sent by the second respondent. Whether the opinion of the Second Respondent that, the execution of the work is unsatisfactory, was in fact warranted, or necessary or could be accepted, in view of present Court, need not be tested or decided, in these writ petitions. If the Petitioner is aggrieved by the opinion, it has liberty to challenge the same. Present is not a fit case for issuing a Writ of Mandamus to accept the work completion certificate and process the tender document of the Petitioner. Writ Petitions dismissed.

Relevant : Jagdish Mandal vs. State of Orissa and Ors. MANU/SC/0090/2007

Tags : TENDER   CERTIFICATE   ACCEPTANCE  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved