SC Condemns Witch-Hunting, Says Superstition Continues to Override Constitutional Morality  ||  SC: Retired Judges Appointed to Central Industrial Tribunals Not Entitled to Pay Parity  ||  SC: Electricity Boards Liable for Electrocution Deaths under Strict, Not Absolute Liability  ||  Supreme Court Criticizes Courts For Conducting ‘Mini-Trials’ in Temporary Injunction Matters  ||  SC: Common Judgment in Suits by Same Plaintiff can be Challenged Through Composite Appeal  ||  Chandigarh Court Orders Meta to Take Down AI-Generated Video of Punjab MLA Sukhpal Khaira  ||  Delhi HC: Insolvency Professionals Must Collect & Deposit GST Even if they are Advocates  ||  Madras HC Rejects Election Petition Challenging Colachel MLA Tharahai Cuthbert  ||  Supreme Court: Uncrystallized Contractual Damages Not an Operational Debt under Section 9 IBC  ||  Supreme Court: Interest Accrued in Suspense Account After NPA Classification is Recoverable as Debt    

National Stock Exchange of India Limited v. Moneywise Media Private Limited and Ors. - (High Court of Bombay) (09 Sep 2015)

NSE’s defamation claim against article alleging benefits to select traders rejected

MANU/MH/2384/2015

Capital Market

Mere boldness, strength of expression, or even exaggeration does not make a comment unfair; Plaintiffs will succeed if a reasonable person would not have been moved to draw conclusions or make statements the Defendants have. The National Stock Exchange had claimed before the Bombay High Court that articles published by Sucheta Dalal and Debashish Basu on their website were defamatory. The articles, based on information provided in an anonymous letter, had alleged illicit trading advantages afforded by NSE to select algorithmic trades, which benefited from premium co-location access, reducing their latency. The Court, declining the application for injunction, noted the influential role Sucheta Dalal had played in bringing to light the ‘Harshad Mehta scam’ in 1992 and dismissed “petty-minded” assertions of the NSE that she was prone to scare-mongering or populism.

Relevant : Shree Maheshwar Hydel Power Corporation Ltd. v. Chitroopa Palit & Anr.MANU/MH/1008/2003 Rajagopal v. State of Tamil NaduMANU/SC/0056/1995 Devidas Ramachandra Tuljapurkar v. State of Maharashtra MANU/SC/0612/2015

Tags : DEFAMATION   NSE   ANONYMOUS   JOURNALISM  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved