J&K&L HC: Repeat Narcotics Offences After Release Can Justify Preventive Detention  ||  SC: Departmental Enquiry Required for Police Arrests Without Written Grounds  ||  SC: Preliminary Issue Cannot Be Tried Separately Once Trial on All Issues Has Begun  ||  SC: Police Claim of Sufficient Material for Chargesheet Does Not Entitle Accused to Default Bail  ||  Telangana HC: Father’s Role Beyond Financial Support Cannot Be Overlooked in Custody Matters  ||  Allahabad HC: Hindu Marriage Requires Essential Ceremonies, Arya Samaj Certificate Not Enough  ||  Delhi HC: Narco Test Cannot Be Forced on an Accused Without Consent  ||  Gujarat HC: Brothel Customer Not Liable for Operating Premises or Procuring Women  ||  MP HC: Civil Suits May Be Consolidated Where Issues and Evidence Are Common  ||  J&K&L HC: Personal-Enmity Assaults Concern Law and Order, Not Preventive Detention    

Mx Sumana Pramanik @ Suman Pramanik Vs. Union of India and Ors. - (High Court of Calcutta) (02 Feb 2021)

Right to life includes the right to live with dignity.

MANU/WB/0060/2021

Constitution

In the present case, CSIR–UGC NET has not provided reservation to transgender community. There was no reason for there being no reservation, age relaxation and fee concession for the transgender community in the Joint CSIR-UGC NET Examinations. Despite the approval being granted by the UGC, particularly for the transgender community, and since such reservation and benefits have been accorded, CSIR-UGC NET failed to do so, infringing the right enshrined under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India.

The Court observed and mentioned that right to life, as interpreted and explained by Supreme Court of India and various other High Courts, includes right to live with dignity.

Non- grant of such reservation, age relaxation and free concession for the transgender community for the said examination is unacceptable and patently violative of Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Contravention to such right not only violates Article 14 but also the right to life as enshrined under the Constitution itself. Thus, present appeal allowed directing immediate relaxation in reservation, age relaxation and fee concession for the transgender community in the Joint CSIR-UGC NET Examinations.

Tags : RESERVATION   TRANSGENDER COMMUNITY   CSIR–UGC NET  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2026 - All Rights Reserved