Lok Sabha Confirms Imposition of President Rule in Manipur  ||  AP HC: Court Possesses Limited Scope of Judicial Review in Transfer Cases on Account of Exigencies  ||  Bom. HC: Can’t Evict Tenants Under Arbitration Act if Occupying Premises Falling under DA  ||  Delhi High Court Passes Permanent Injunction in Favour of ‘Peak XV Partners’  ||  Bombay HC: Condition that Younger Candidate Would be Preferred Over Older Candidate Violates COI  ||  Kar. HC Refuses to Entertain Petition Seeking Implementation of Circular Regarding Usage of ‘Dalit’  ||  Kar. HC: Rapido, Uber Can’t Operate in State Unless Relevant Guidelines Issued  ||  Delhi HC: Preserve CCTV Footage When Complaint against Dept. Regarding Illegal Detention in Received  ||  SC Refuses to Direct States to Establish Public Libraries  ||  SC: To Prevent Re-Litigation, Quasi-Judicial Bodies are Bound by Principles of Res-Judicata    

Maryland v. James Kulbicki - (05 Oct 2015)

How effective must counsel be?

Criminal

The United States Supreme Court reversed a ruling that James Kulbicki’s defense team were unconstitutionally ineffective and had deprived him of a fair trial. Kulbicki was accused of shooting his mistress pointblank and prosecution had relied on the ‘similar’ characteristics of the metal fragments found in his mistress’s brain, those found in his truck and matched the same to a bullet recovered from his gun. Kulbicki’s petition against ineffectiveness of counsel stemmed from their failure to question the legitimacy of the report admitting bullet comparisons. The Court of Appeal determined Counsel’s failure to identify the report as against scientific method “fell short of prevailing professional norms”. In its reversal of the finding, the Supreme Court noted there was no rationale behind the judgment, which only proposed an alternate trial strategy based on hindsight; counsel had not wasted time in what was, at the time, an uncontroversial analysis; their failure to find a report to question the ballistics methodology would have required rigorous manual search in State libraries.

Tags : UNITED STATES. EFFECTIVENESS   COUNSEL  

Share :        

Disclaimer | Copyright 2025 - All Rights Reserved